Market Breadth Data******************************

Friday, November 06, 2026

A Bounce, Not a Repair

 A hot payrolls report steadied the tape but did not repair it. October jobs smashed expectations (+165K vs ~65K), yields rose, and a December Fed hike became the base case — yet the S&P managed only +0.31%, reclaiming barely a twentieth of Thursday's 4.36% plunge, while chips led a Nasdaq bounce and the Dow slipped. The week ends with the S&P down 2.7%, its worst week since April 2025. Tuesday's CPI is now the next test.

 

Today’s key data & market reaction

 

·        October employment report (5:30 AM PT / 8:30 AM ET): nonfarm payrolls +165K vs ~65K expected (Reuters poll; 59K Dow Jones consensus), the strongest print relative to expectations in months. September revised up to +60K (from +29K) and August to +186K (from +133K) — combined revisions +84K, lifting the 3-month average to ~137K.

·        Unemployment rate: 4.1% (unrounded 4.141%) vs 4.2% expected/previous — back to the level held through most of mid-2026. Labor force participation ticked up to 61.9% (from 61.8%); household employment rose 463K. U-6 underemployment rose to 7.9% (from 7.6%).

·        Wages: average hourly earnings +0.4% m/m to $38.00, +3.1% y/y — below the pace of inflation, so real hourly earnings fell.

·        Market reaction: yields rose and the dollar strengthened — the strong print cemented a December hike as the market's base case (market-implied hike odds ~78% after the release, vs ~77–78% before; no material change on the odds watch). The 10Y rose to ~4.86% and the 2Y to ~4.51%. Equities opened higher on the print, then faded well off session highs — the S&P finished +0.31% after being up ~0.9% intraday. The bounce was chip-led, not broad: the Dow fell and the S&P reclaimed only ~7% of Thursday's point loss.

 

Session recap

 

Indices · versus Thursday’s close

·        S&P 500: 7,376.86, +23.13 (+0.31%). Week: -2.7%, worst week since April 2025 and its fourth consecutive weekly loss. Now -5.7% below the Oct 6 record close of 7,818.93.

·        Nasdaq Composite: 24,579.42, +264.42 (+1.09%). Week: -3.4%. Nasdaq 100: 27,159.56, +1.99%, still ~13% below its Oct 6 record close.

·        Dow: 51,285.73, -237.33 (-0.46%), after spending much of the morning in positive territory. Week: -0.9%.

·        Russell 2000: 2,754.11, +24.22 (+0.89%). Week: ~-2.0%.

·        VIX: 23.67, -16% (from 28.18 Thursday) — a big retracement of Thursday's ~70% spike, but still well above Wednesday's 16.61.

 

Sectors / stocks: Tech and communication services led; the iShares Semiconductor ETF (SOXX) rose 3.5% after plunging 12% Thursday. AMD +11% (after -17% Thursday), Intel +8%, Micron +5%, Nvidia +~3%. Cloudflare and Airbnb rose on beat-and-raise quarters; Qualcomm, Microchip and Atlassian fell despite earnings beats — execution no longer overcomes doubt about the AI capex cycle. Energy inched higher; precious metals fell. The tech sector ETF is down ~8% for the week, its fifth straight weekly loss.

 

Rates: 2Y ~4.51% (+4bp); 10Y ~4.86% (+1–2bp); 30Y ~5.25% (-1bp). Curve marginally flatter at the long end; the front end did the repricing on the hike read.

USD: DXY ~102.2, +~0.6% — reclaiming the 102 level; EUR/USD below 1.115 (-0.6%); USD/JPY above 158.

Commodities: WTI ~$90.20/bbl (-0.4%); Brent ~$97.44 (-0.9%). Gold ~$4,073/oz (-1.0%), holding above $4,050; silver ~$52.00 (-0.7%).

Crypto: BTC ~$75,800–75,900, little changed — lagged the tech bounce and sits near its September low; ETH ~$2,235.

 

 

Dominant narrative: a very strong jobs report removed the growth-scare excuse for Thursday's rout but replaced it with a hawkish one — resilient labor plus sticky inflation keeps the Fed on a hiking path into December, so the bounce was narrow, chip-led, and faded into the close.

 

 

Gann, Elliott & Hurst insights (interpretive, not forecasts)

 

Gann

·        Time: today is 31 calendar days after the Oct 6 record close (7,818.93) — just past the 30-day window flagged yesterday, in which the decline landed. Next Gann windows: ~45 days from the Oct 6 top lands ~Nov 20 (also monthly options-expiry week); 60 days lands ~Dec 5.

·        Price: the close at 7,376.86 held above the ~7,350 area for a second straight session — a tentative base, but the bounce reclaimed only ~7% of Thursday's 335-point drop, far short of a meaningful retracement of the leg. Key Gann levels: support at ~7,200 (round number / ~8% off the high) and ~7,037 (10% correction line off the record close); resistance at 7,688.62 (Wednesday's close) and 7,818.93 (record).

·        Price-time: the Oct 6 high to the Nov 5 low traced a near-vertical leg; Gann work treats such legs as vulnerable to a fast retracement once a base forms — the base has not yet formed, only a first bounce.

 

Elliott Wave

·        Primary count (unchanged): the advance into the Oct 6 top completed a 5-wave impulse (or a wave-3 top) off the April 2025 lows; the decline since is a wave-4 correction — or the A-wave of a larger correction if it deepens. Friday's weak, narrow bounce keeps both readings live.

·        Alternate: the Oct 6 top was only wave 3 of a larger advance, and this is a sharp wave 4 finding its footing near the 10% correction line (~7,037 S&P).

·        Confirm/invalidate: a daily close back above 7,688.62 (Wednesday's close) would argue the decline is a completed ABC; a close below 7,037 would confirm a deeper corrective phase with the next magnet near the 200-day area in the high 6,800s–6,900s. The Nasdaq's +1.09% vs the S&P's +0.31% divergence is notable but not yet a confirmation either way.

 

Hurst Cycles

·        The decline from the Oct 6 top is ~23 trading days — the nominal ~20-day cycle is inside its trough window right now (Nov 5–7), and Friday's bounce is consistent with a 20-day trough attempt. But the S&P's feeble +0.31% leaves the trough unconfirmed; a failed bounce here would be the bearish resolution.

·        The ~40-day cycle is mid-down-phase, with its trough due mid-to-late November; the ~80-day cycle peaked in early October and is still declining.

·        The ~20-week cycle remains above its midline but is rolling over from its October peak.

·        Alignment: mixed-to-down — short cycle near trough, intermediate cycles still falling. A hold above ~7,200 into mid-November would be the constructive read; a break of it into the 40-day trough window would point lower.

 

Synthesis: all three frameworks still agree the Oct 6 top marked a significant peak and the decline is not yet confirmed complete; they disagree on whether Friday was the start of the 20-day-cycle bounce (Hurst/Gann timing says the window is now) or a dead-cat bounce before a deeper leg toward the 10% line (Elliott says the level decides — and Friday's weak breadth argues the bounce is unproven).

 

Next session preview — Monday, November 9

 

·        NY Fed Consumer Inflation Expectations (October survey) — 8:00 AM PT / 11:00 AM ET. The 1-year expectation is the one to watch: it feeds directly into the inflation debate ahead of Tuesday's CPI and the December FOMC decision.

·        Wholesale Inventories (September) — 7:00 AM PT / 10:00 AM ET. A second-tier release; a soft inventory read would add a small dovish note to the growth picture.

·        Fed speakers: Chicago's Goolsbee, Richmond's Barkin and Vice Chair for Supervision Bowman all speak Monday — the first Fed voices after the hot payrolls print; listen for any pushback on the market's December-hike pricing. BoE Governor Bailey also speaks Monday, his first public appearance since Thursday's hike to 4.00%.

·        The week's main event is Tuesday: October CPI — 5:30 AM PT / 8:30 AM ET, consensus +0.3% m/m (vs +0.6% prior), y/y prior 3.7%. It is the last CPI the FOMC sees before the Dec 8–9 decision. NFIB small business optimism is also due Tuesday (3:00 AM PT / 6:00 AM ET).

·        Seasonality: Monday opens the first full week after the midterms with the market now two sessions past the election and the initial rally fully reversed. No options expiry until monthly OpEx on Nov 20. Friday payrolls days are historically among the most volatile sessions of the month — today's fade off the highs leaves the tape fragile into a CPI week; Mondays after a -2.7% week tend to test whether the bounce attempt holds or fails at the open.


Markets catch their breath
Autumn winds shake golden leaves
Dusk holds quiet hope

 

Thursday, November 05, 2026

What the Record Says About Days Like This

SPY fell 4.4% today and the VIX jumped to 28.2. In tests back to 1990, a VIX above 20 is when all four CIT dip buys did their best: about twice the edge per trade of calm days.


Today

MarketCloseToday
S&P 500 (SPY)733.00-4.4%
Nasdaq 100 (QQQ)647.05-6.5%
Russell 2000 (IWM)270.98-4.6%
Dow (DIA)514.27-3.5%
VIX28.18+69.7%

SPY closed above its 200-day average (727), 0.8% over it. That matters in the next table, and it is a thin margin: another day like today would put SPY in the weaker row.

After days like this

Every day since 1993 that SPY fell 3% or more with the VIX above 20, counted once per sell-off (the first day, then nothing for a month), and SPY's gain after it:

Sell-offs1 week1 month3 months
All
(43)
+0.62%
56% up
+1.29%
63% up
+4.93%
77% up
SPY above
200-day (16)
+1.99%
81% up
+1.79%
75% up
+6.03%
88% up
SPY below
200-day (31)
-0.11%
45% up
+0.56%
55% up
+4.30%
71% up
Any day,
for scale
+0.23%
59% up
+0.96%
66% up
+2.89%
72% up

Each cell is SPY's average gain and how often it was higher. The worst 3 months after one of these days: -7.8% when SPY was above its 200-day, -29.2% when it was below.

Sixteen is a small sample, and it holds the worst case too: on February 24, 2020, SPY was also above its 200-day, and a month later it was 24% lower. Below the 200-day, the first two weeks were usually worse before they were better.

Why the VIX matters for the dip buys

The four CIT dip buys buy short, sharp drops and sell on the first strong close, usually within 3 to 5 days. Split by the VIX on the day of the signal, every one of them did better when fear was high. Edge is the trade's gain minus the average of 50 random entries in the same stock held just as long, so it is what the signal added beyond being in the stock.

Edge per trade, 2005 to 2026: Dow 30 stocks, IWM, GLD, TLT

RuleVIX 20 or lessVIX above 20VIX above 25
QS RSI+0.25+0.83+1.37
CIT MACD Dip+0.18+0.98+1.39
CIT ComboRSI Dip+0.18+0.74+1.26
CIT RSI+VWAP Dip+0.09+0.45+0.76

Edge per trade, 2005 to 2026: SPY, QQQ, S&P 500, Nasdaq 100

RuleVIX 20 or lessVIX above 20VIX above 25
QS RSI+0.39+1.01+1.28
CIT MACD Dip+0.62+1.29+1.70
CIT ComboRSI Dip+0.25+0.78+1.25
CIT RSI+VWAP Dip+0.43+0.73+0.98

The same test on 1990 to 2004, an earlier stretch of data, came out the same way: all 8 rule and market pairs had more edge with the VIX above 20 (stocks +0.30 to +0.50 points on calm days, +0.64 to +0.94 above 20). Winners ran roughly 70% for stocks and 70 to 85% for the indexes in every bucket; what changes is how much the winners make.

The price: bigger losers. With the VIX above 20 the worst QS RSI stock trade was -38.9%, against -18.9% on calm days. The rules have no stop; they wait for the bounce, up to 60 days.

The CIT Pullback


The slower cousin: a close above the 200-day average and below the prior 7-day low, after a down run that has lasted longer than usual (the CIT Swing Count at or past its 1σ length). It sells on a close above the 5-day average. Edge per trade on the Dow 30 and the index funds: +0.51 points in 2005 to 2026 and +1.20 with the VIX above 20; +1.05 and +1.24 in 1990 to 2004. It is on the AI page in OT Trend.


The last three months

The other side of the same table: over the last three months the live record of the four rules was 3,705 trades, 57% winners, 0.53 points a trade behind random days. The VIX averaged 16 and closed above 20 on two days. That is the calm-market column, and it is why a quiet market is not the time to judge a dip buy.

Today's list

At today's close 118 of the 509 stocks and funds scanned had at least one dip buy fire (the number in brackets is how many of the four): MPC (4), P (4), PLTR (4), PSX (4), ADI (3), APA (3), CMI (3), COP (3), CVX (3), DELL (3), DOW (3), EOG (3), EXE (3), EXPD (3), GD (3), IEX (3), ILMN (3), INTC (3), KMI (3), LITE (3), LMT (3), LYB (3), MRVL (3), MU (3), NDSN (3), NUE (3), OKE (3), OXY (3), PANW (3), SLB (3), STLD (3), TDY (3), TEL (3), TRGP (3), TSLA (3), TXN (3), URI (3), VLO (3), XOM (3), AEP (2) and 78 more. Among the funds: QQQ, IWM, SPY.

61 earlier trades are still open. The list, with each one's exit level, updates after every close in the CIT Dip Buys watchlist in OddsTrader. A signal is a rule firing, not a recommendation.

Exits: the next open after a close above the prior day's high (the CIT MACD Dip sells at that close); the CIT RSI+VWAP Dip sells the next open after RSI(3) closes above 55. 60 days at most.

How the tests were run: daily bars, fills as stated, no commissions or slippage; the sell-off table uses SPY with dividends. Past results don't promise future ones, and this is not investment advice.


Terms of Use

All rights reserved by the author. The material contained herein is original content and is the sole property of the author. Any commercial use or reproduction - either in part or whole - is strictly forbidden without the author's prior consent.

Disclaimer: The information provided here is for educational purposes only and does not constitute trading advice nor an invitation to buy or sell securities. The views are the personal views of the author. Before acting on any of the ideas expressed, the reader should seek professional advice to determine the suitability in view of his or her personal circumstances.