Two different volume readings flashed the same message this week: the selling is coming in clusters, not single days. One measures the whole NYSE, the other SPY’s own trading. Below is what each one shows and what SPY did after similar stretches before.
1. NYSE down volume: four heavy days in six sessions
On Thursday (Nov 19), 86% of NYSE volume went into falling
stocks and 82% of issues declined. On its own that is a heavy day, not a rare
one. What stands out is the clustering: it was the fourth day of 78% or more
NYSE down volume in the last six sessions (Nov 12: 80%, Nov 16: 78%, Nov 17:
79%, Nov 19: 86%).
What SPY did after heavy NYSE selling, 1998 to 2026
|
Signal (NYSE down volume) |
Cases |
After 5 days |
After 20 days |
After 60 days |
|
All days |
7,010 |
+0.2%
(58% up) |
+0.8%
(64%) |
+2.3%
(70%) |
|
85% or more |
189 |
+0.4%
(60% up) |
+1.3%
(66%) |
+3.4%
(70%) |
|
90% or more |
107 |
+0.5%
(55% up) |
+1.2%
(64%) |
+4.4%
(72%) |
|
3rd day of 78%+ within 6 sessions |
71 |
+1.4%
(70% up) |
+1.9%
(67%) |
+5.2%
(74%) |
2. SPY’s own volume: three heavy down days in four sessions
SPY fell 2.0% on Thursday to $715.87 on 76 million shares,
1.65 times its 50-day average. It was the third down day in four sessions with
volume at 1.5 times the average or more (Nov 16: 1.54x, Nov 17: 1.57x, Nov 19:
1.65x).
SPY’s volume shows three such clusters since June. In June,
SPY made its low (about 725) inside the cluster and rallied to 778 by early
August. The Oct 30 to Nov 5 cluster included the biggest volume day of the
period (126 million shares, 3 times the average) and was followed by a bounce
to 760. This one is different: all three heavy days are down days, and SPY is
at a new low for the period with no bounce yet.
What SPY did after its own heavy-volume selling, 1993 to 2026
|
Signal (SPY volume) |
Cases |
After 5 days |
After 20 days |
After 60 days |
|
All days |
8,400+ |
+0.2%
(58% up) |
+0.8%
(64%) |
+2.3%
(70%) |
|
3rd heavy-volume down day within 6
sessions |
63 |
+0.3%
(65% up) |
+1.5%
(68%) |
+3.9%
(73%) |
What stands out
Both say the same thing
Whether you count heavy selling across the NYSE or in SPY
itself, a cluster of heavy days was followed by better-than-normal returns:
about twice the normal 20-day gain and better odds. Repeated selling tends to
use up the sellers.
More selling usually comes first
After an 85%+ NYSE down-volume day, another one followed
within 10 sessions more than half the time (106 of 189), and the median low
over the next 20 days was 1.9% below that day’s close. In SPY’s own clusters
the median case also saw a close 2.4% lower within 20 days. Feb 25, 2020 was
one of those cases, and it came before the worst of that crash.
Not a guaranteed low
The edge shows up over one to three months, not in a
straight line. The fall of 2023 had a similar stretch: after the third heavy
NYSE day (Oct 3), more heavy days followed and SPY fell another 2.6% over three
weeks before the low on Oct 27.
What to watch
An up day on heavy volume
In SPY, a heavy-volume up day would be the first sign the
selling is being absorbed, as on Jun 11 and Nov 4. More heavy down days at
lower closes would mean the cluster is still building.
The oversold gauge turning up inside the cluster
The oversold gauge we track is deep in its low zone, in the
lowest 1.3% of all readings since 2004. Its strongest buy signal in back-tests
is the day its slower reading turns back up from oversold, and that has not
happened yet.
When the turn came during a NYSE selling cluster (three or
more days of 78%+ NYSE down volume within six sessions), SPY was higher 20 days
later in 22 of 25 cases since 2007, by about 5% on average (3.7% without the
2009 and 2020 rebounds), against about 3% for the turn on its own. The misses
were Oct 2008 (-8.6%), Jun 2010 (-2.0%) and Oct 2023 (-0.5%). 25 cases is a
small sample, so I treat it as a confirmation, not a system.
Timing matters
The six-session window moves forward each day and older
heavy days drop out of it. With Nov 16, 17 and 19 in the window, a turn on
Friday (Nov 20) or Monday (Nov 23) would still count. From Tuesday on it needs
fresh 78%+ days to keep the cluster alive.
This is a record of what happened, not a forecast. For
information only. Not investment advice.

